Urban Fantasy Review: Witchful Thinking by HP Mallory (Not For Me)

Posted February 11, 2012 by Felicia S in 2.00 Wine Glasses, 2012 Read / 6 Comments


Author Website

From Goodreads: From H. P. Mallory—the exciting author of Fire Burn and Cauldron Bubble—comes her new paranormal romance featuring the sassy, self-deprecating witch Jolie Wilkins.
Jolie thinks she’s seen it all, but life continues to spring surprises. The latest shocker? She’s just been crowned Queen of the Underworld. Jolie may possess a rare gift for reanimating the dead, but she doesn’t know the first thing about governing disparate factions of supernatural creatures. She can barely maintain order in her own chaotic personal life, which is heading into a romantic tailspin.

First there’s sexy warlock Rand, the love of her life, from whom Jolie is hiding a devastating secret. Then there’s Sinjin, a darkly seductive vampire and Jolie’s sworn protector—though others suspect he harbors ulterior motives. As the two polar opposite yet magnetic men vie for Jolie’s affection, she must keep her wits about her to balance affairs of state and affairs of her heart. Overwhelmed, under pressure, and longing for love, Jolie decides it’s time to take charge—and show everyone that this queen won’t take jack

Read from January 05 to February 11, 2012 (yes it took me that long)

Won from Library Thing Early Reviewers
Overall Rating 2.00
Story Rating 2.00
Character Rating 2.00

Final thought when finished: Not my cup of tea at all though I still highly recommend the rest of the series. I really hope this isn’t because she went with a publisher that insisted on playing up the romance.

Why I gave it a 2 (not using my normal review method): I really wanted to like this book as much as I did the first two in the series. However, I am not a fan of love triangles. It irks me when teenagers are in them and irks me even more when grown adults are in them. I have kind of up to this point, ignored the triangle in this series because it wasn’t the focus. However, Witchful Thinking was one big ode to the love triangle. There wasn’t any furthering of the more compelling story (which I won’t give away in case you haven’t read the first two) and in the end, I was left wanting. I love HP Mallory’s writing. She has some great story telling ability. This, however, didn’t work for me personally. If you are a fan of love triangles, you will love this particular entry into the series. It is all about Sinjun, Rand, and Jolie. If you are not a fan of triangles, then I would suggest skipping this entry. I don’t think you would be missing much of significance in the overall series.

Felicia S
Follow Me

What are your thoughts?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

6 responses to “Urban Fantasy Review: Witchful Thinking by HP Mallory (Not For Me)

  1. Natalie (Mindful Mus

    NOT ANOTHER LOVE TRIANGLE!!! I'm starting to feel like I need the love triangle version of bug spray when I go into a bookstore these days (though the mosquitoes always seemed to ignore my bathing in OFF and just went at it anyways).

  2. Missie, The Unread R

    *sobs buckets*Well, this hurts! I'm definitely not a fan of love triangles either, especially in adult series. I rather the couple I'm rooting for play that cat and mouse game.Thanks for the warning. I'll definitely be skipping it for now. *runs off to cry in a corner*

  3. Blodeuedd

    Too bad it did not do more for you :/ Well that's the life of a booklover. Gotta take the good and the bad

  4. Felicia Sparks

    I was so very disappointed. I am like you, after book 2 I thought the triangle was pretty null and void. Not so much….*sigh*

  5. Amanda

    What the f! I feel like after what happened in book 2 that the love triangle would not have been necessary. I was annoyed enough with the love triangle in the previous book that I don't think I could deal with it again.I think I'll be skipping this book. Hopefully the next in the series will be better.